Officers dismissed for excessive force on elderly care home resident in Sussex

Two Sussex Police officers have been dismissed without notice for using excessive force on a 92-year-old, wheelchair-bound care home resident.

PC Stephen Smith and PC Rachel Comotto are set to be included on the police's barred list following a disciplinary hearing concluding today, after an investigation by the Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC).

The officers responded to a report of a knife threat at a care home in St Leonards-on-Sea on 21st June 2022.

The resident involved was Donald Burgess, who was isolated in a room holding a cutlery knife.

According to police body-worn footage, PC Smith instructed Mr Burgess to drop the knife or face being "sprayed or Tasered."

Within 90 seconds, the officers deployed force, with PC Smith using PAVA spray and striking Mr Burgess with a baton, while PC Comotto used her Taser.

Mr Burgess was subsequently handcuffed, taken to hospital, and passed away on 13th July, although a pathologist determined the officers' actions did not contribute to his death.

The disciplinary panel found both officers guilty of breaching conduct standards relating to use of force, discreditable conduct, and authority, respect, and courtesy.

PC Comotto also faced a separate allegation for a Facebook post she made shortly after the incident.

In the post, she commented, "We all know what happens in care homes" followed by a lightning emoji in response to a friend's post regarding birthday celebrations and care homes.

Emily Barry, IOPC Director of Engagement, stressed the impact of the officers' misconduct.

"Our thoughts and sympathies remain with Mr Burgess's family. This incident has caused widespread concern and anger, as Mr Burgess, who posed little risk, was subjected to excessive force, which should have been a last resort.

"The officers have damaged public trust in policing. Their actions were excessive, unreasonable and exacerbated by PC Comotto's poor judgement shown on social media."

The IOPC investigation commenced in June 2022 and concluded six months later.

The Crown Prosecution Service received evidence in June 2023, and in May 2025, the officers were acquitted of assault charges.

Hear the latest news on Clyde 1 on FM, DAB, smart speaker or the Rayo app.