Surgeon calls for public inquiry claiming there have been 'dozens of avoidable deaths' at NHS Grampian

Dr Mohammed Habib made the allegations during a press conference held earlier today.

Dr Mohammed Meer Habib,
Author: Liam RossPublished 11 hours ago
Last updated 5 hours ago

A practising NHS Grampian surgeon has alleged there have been "dozens" of avoidable deaths at the health board over many years.

Dr Mohammed Habib, who has been a consultant surgeon at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary (ARI) since July 2014, says he has raised major concerns for 10 years, but claims to have been ignored.

The whistleblower has released information from an unpublished review which states that 19 of the 20 deaths he reported were avoidable.

Dr Habib is now calling for NHS Grampian to face a Corporate Homicide review and a public inquiry as he feels there was a gross breach of duty of care and various breaches caused or materially contributed to patient deaths.

This comes after a damning report into the health board was published by Healthcare Improvement Scotland (HIS) was published last week, stating that there were serious weaknesses with NHS Grampian senior leadership.

Claims NHS Grampian guilty of 'wicked recklessness'

Speaking at a media conference held alongside the lawyer Aamer Anwar, Dr Habib said: "The HPB (Hepatopancreatobiliary) and General Surgery Service at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary (ARI) has operated on thousands of patients from 2010 to date.

"Whilst the expected maximum mortality rate for HPB surgery is around 2% for minor surgery and for major surgery is up to 5% but this team had a mortality of 15-20% for major surgery, year on year.

"I know that since 2010 several hundred patients would have come to harm from an excessively high rate of complications but the trust failed to collect data.

"I became worried in 2016 about avoidable surgery related deaths. In July 2021 I formally raised serious concerns about excessive mortality in surgery, 45 cases with 20 deaths. This related to what I believe to be dozens of avoidable deaths.

"In February 2024 I reported 20 cases from years 2015-2022 of possible culpable/corporate homicide to Police Scotland. I have had several interviews with Police Scotland. In December 2025 I was informed it was progressing yet heard nothing since.

"These cases relating to Aberdeen Royal Infirmary, I believe are due to poor decision making, poor technique, and recklessness as well as many other factors which in my view is tantamount to corporate homicide.

"In all the cases I reported they were in my opinion guilty of wicked recklessness and an indifference to patient deaths as outcome and NHS Grampian knew enough to have stopped it from happening.

"Two examples of Culpable/Corporate Homicide case are where patients were advised they would be operated on for a certain procedure, but instead they were given the wrong operation and they died - their families were not informed of the what really happened."

He says an external expert case note review was instructed by NHS Grampian and concluded 19 of 20 deaths he reported were avoidable.

He also claims that review identified recurring problems with lack of leadership, poor decision making, poor pre-operative planning and patient optimisation and inadequate surgical technique.

Dr Habib said he believes "the reality of poor outcomes was concealed."

He added: "I wish to state most recently there appeared to be public disclosure about one operative death in ARI, and plan to learn from reviews but there has been no mention of repeat review to correct the mistakes. This is just the tip of the iceberg.

Aamer Anwar and Dr Mohammed Habib speaking at a media conference earlier

"The question for me is not just about the 20 deaths I was able to report on, but what about 100s of other patients who may have suffered significant harm or avoidable deaths.

"NHS Grampian are holding the key to the Pandora’s box and I believe they are deliberately not opening the box.

"They are avoiding accountability by not being transparent about what damage has been done, while promising heaven and earth going forward.

"In every other death at the hands of the state, families would be entitled to understand that circumstances of their loved ones’ death, we can’t ‘draw a line in the sand’ as Angela Constance (Scotland's Health Secretary) has said, families deserve to know how and why their loved one died.

"I demand a public inquiry into the events at NHSG and for Police Scotland and Crown Office to expedite a full-scale criminal investigation.

"Patients who suffered complications or deaths since 2010, to be given the opportunity to have their cases formally investigated so they can decide what legal steps they wish to take.

"To conclude, I love being a surgeon and have given a lifetime to the care of patients, I also wish to state that I deeply respect many of the front-line staff who work at NHS Grampian. It is time that they are supported and listened to if things are to truly change for the best."

Claims of 'slaughterhouse' operating theatre

Lawyer Aamer Anwar also read out a detailed statement, and called for the health board's Chief Executive to resign and said NHS Grampian must now be escalated to the highest level of Government intervention.

He said: "Catastrophically, the operation theatre he worked in, at times could be described as a ‘slaughterhouse’, which killed through incompetence and negligence, whilst not giving a damn for accountability.

"On Tuesday, the Health Secretary Angela Constance made a statement on NHS Grampian in light of a damning report on its leadership, yet that merely scratches the surface of an industrial scale ‘cover up’ at NHS Grampian.

"The measures unveiled by Angela Constance fail to deal with a deep-rooted culture of denial, arrogance and incompetence.

"Rather than listening to front line staff, the priority for some senior management appeared to be saving their own careers, rather than patient’s lives."

"Patient safety remains our highest priority" - NHS Grampian

NHS Grampian Chief Executive, Laura Skaife-Knight, outlined how an investigation has already taken place with work ongoing.

She said: "We are aware of the serious allegations raised today. A thorough investigation has already taken place into these matters, with some elements of that work ongoing.

"Any new evidence or information will be carefully considered, and NHS Grampian will continue to respond through the appropriate clinical, governance and legal processes.

"We understand the allegations will cause further concern to patients, members of the public and staff.

"It is important we respect patient and employee confidentiality, but we can highlight that where reviews identify issues around patient care, the appropriate Duty of Candour processes are followed.

"This includes direct communication with patients and families where required.

"If our consideration of any new evidence identifies further individuals who should be contacted, we will do so.

"Patient safety remains our highest priority."

A spokesperson for Healthcare Improvement Scotland said: “Healthcare Improvement Scotland takes the concerns raised by Dr Habib extremely seriously.

“As the reports published last week illustrate, we have repeatedly escalated matters of concern about NHS Grampian. We expect NHS Grampian to implement the recommendations urgently to improve the quality and safety of care provided for their patients.”

'Any criminal investigation is a police matter' - Scottish Government

The Scottish Government have outlined in a statement they raised Dr Habib's concerns with the healthcare watchdog and NHS Grampian.

A spokesperson said: “We recognise the courage shown by this whistleblower to raise concerns. Everyone who works in our NHS should feel safe and supported to speak up without fear of detriment.

“Ministers have already committed to transparently setting out all engagement with NHS Grampian in relation to the concerns raised in the HIS Review.

“The Government took action and repeatedly raised the concerns of Dr Habib with both Healthcare Improvement Scotland and NHS Grampian. As the HIS Review set out last week, there were clear failures in the former medical leadership and in how concerns were being addressed within NHS Grampian.

"NHS Grampian is now subject to a very significant level of intervention and an unprecedented level of support.

“Any criminal investigation is a matter for Police Scotland.”

Detective Superintendent Carron McKellar said: “We received a report in 2024 following several deaths.

"Enquiries are being carried out, and a situational report will be submitted to the Procurator Fiscal.”

Listen to KISS, KISSTORY and KISS Xtra on our free Rayo app, by hitting the play button on the bottom of your screen and on your smart speaker (‘Play KISS FM’, ‘Play KISSTORY’, ‘Play KISS Fresh’). KISS and KISSTORY are also available on DAB.