Brother-in-law of the Princess of Wales defends gate installation in public footpath dispute

The brother-in-law of the Princess of Wales has defended the installation of an electric security gate on his property amid an inquiry over whether part of his drive should be designated as a public footpath.

James Matthews, who is married to Kate’s sister Pippa, spoke at a planning inquiry, highlighting the need for increased security at Barton Court at Kintbury in West Berkshire, due to his family’s high public profile.

In September 2022, Matthews erected the electric gate, leading to the walking group West Berkshire Ramblers applying for a modification order in January 2023, aiming to establish the drive as a public footpath.

Inquiry Details

West Berkshire District Council investigated the application and found the footpath route reasonably alleged to exist based on evidence, legislation, and case law.

Matthews objected, arguing that the path was infrequently used and the installation of the gate did not draw objections from the local parish council or neighbours.

At the Kintbury Coronation Hall inquiry, Matthews said he was unaware of any public use of the drive when purchasing the property in August 2022, adding that the gate is for securing his family.

He asserted that only occasionally has he seen individuals, never groups, walking along the drive, communicating that it is private property.

Contrasting Opinions

The inquiry revealed differing perspectives: while former estate manager David Hill claims sporadic encounters with lost individuals, witness Anthony Stansfeld argued the path has always been private. Other statements countered Matthews' claims, recalling previous unhindered access to the purported footpath.

A spokesperson for the Matthews family defended their rights to a secure private environment, particularly for their young children.

The inquiry continues in Kintbury with testimony from various community members regarding the path's historical use.

Hear all the latest news from across the UK on the hour, every hour, on Greatest Hits Radio on DAB, smartspeaker, at greatesthitsradio.co.uk, and on the Rayo app.